From Gaystar News:
You’d be forgiven for thinking there was hope for reform in the Catholic Church.
At last year’s Synod Pope Francis and his prelates released a more
enlightened document, seeking a more tolerant attitude toward gay
Catholics and priests.
It wasn’t the same this year. We got one paragraph,
with two guidelines: The church doesn’t believe in ‘unjust
discrimination’ of gay people, and gay marriage has ‘no grounds
whatsoever’.
This is not a step back. It’s a sort-of half-hearted response,
shifting uncomfortably, that won’t please conservative or liberal
Catholics.
It isn’t surprising. There was some pipe dreaming before the synod
Pope Francis would push the church toward gay acceptance. There is some
reason to believe this is what he wants; but plenty of reasons to
suspect he’ll never get it.
1. The synod only creates new guidelines
The synod is a meeting of bishops and the pope with the intention of
providing guidelines for Catholics in the modern world. It was never
going to change doctrine. A theological discussion about whether
Christian religion sees homosexuality as sinful has been going on for
decades: but most mainstream Catholics say it is. The bishops attending
the synod, then, saw it as beyond their power to change the church’s
stance on gay people.
2. The Catholic Church isn’t built for change
The Catholic Church is unlike other religions in that it has a
figurehead: the Pope. In most religions, power is decentralized among a
hierarchy of dignitaries. This makes change difficult, because when it
doesn’t come from the top it looks like a challenge to that authority.
Acceptance of gay people isn’t coming from the top but from the secular
world. Unlike governments, the Catholic Church is not a democracy: and
popular demand won’t affect its decisions.
3. LGBT inclusion is not a priority
The reason this synod attracted so much attention is because the church
is in a period of upheaval. It’s not just trying to assimilate modern
values, like acceptance of homosexuality, but a broader base of
Catholics in regions like Africa, while in America and Europe, liberal
and conservative Catholics are distancing themselves from Rome.
4. The church doesn’t reform: it splits
Catholicism has had plenty of chances to evolve in the past, but it
didn’t. The Protestant Church arose out of attempts to reform the
Catholic Church – Protestantism comes from ‘protest’. Just think:
yesterday, the Pope announced they would budge the doctrinal equivalent
of an inch and provide sacrament to divorced people. If that sounds
progressive, think about how they were having this same argument 500
years ago, when Henry VIII tried to divorce Catherine of Aragon. It
didn’t result in reformation but with Henry VIII establishing a Church
of England.
5. Pope Francis may not be so pro-gay
Whether or not the Pope is pro-LGBT is disputed. He’s met with gay
couples and spoke to gay advocacy groups, but also said transgender
people should ‘accept the body God gave you’ and praised ‘traditional’
families as the best there can be. He is also said to have met up with
gay marriage antagonist Kim Davis – who’s not even Catholic. Even if the
Pope was pro-LGBT, he can’t ignore the conservative Bishops, who have
threatened he could be ’separating the church along Protestant lines’.
As long as the church remains predominately Catholic, he’s prevented
from pushing for change.
6. The church is not a Western organization, but a global one
We might think because the papacy is in Rome it will follow along
Italian lines: conservative now, but getting there. But the church has
growing bases in Africa and the Far East, where homosexuality isn’t just
sinful, it’s largely punishable by death. Bishops from these countries
attended the synod and wield increasing power with the papacy.
7. Catholic teachings on gays are dehumanizing: so why would they care?
At this moment, the way gay people are referred to is clinical and
dehumanizing. We are ‘sinful’. In the synod document released yesterday,
it revealingly talks to the families of gay people: not to gay people
themselves. Why? Possibly it thinks it would dirty the pages of a church
(rife in corruption), or doesn’t want to condescend to gay people
(though it teaches humility, and that we are all sinners). Even the
chosen word, ‘homosexuals’, is a throwback to pathologizing textbooks,
when homosexuality was considered a mental illness.
It might be remarkable that in the 21st century the Catholic Church
and its followers can still take such an immobile and even cruel
position on gay Catholics. They wish to appear progressive, but while
saying they want to avoid ‘unjust discrimination’, they don’t provide
any ‘just’ reason for being so discriminatory. The church, flawed and
frayed at the edges, thinks it’s too good for ‘homosexuals’: so why
would it take us seriously?